Cessna T-206H | N712AM

August 29th, 2024 | Yellow Pine, Idaho

Accident Location

  • City: Yellow Pine
  • State: Idaho
  • Latitude: 44.902319
  • Longitude: -115.48692
  • Airport ID: 3U2

Aircraft Info

  • N Number: N712AM
  • Make: Cessna
  • Model: T-206H
  • Aircraft Category: Aircraft Single Engine Land
  • Amateur Built: No

Pilot Info

  • PIC Name: Brown, Charles Robert
  • Gender: Male
  • Pilot Age:
  • Pilot Hours:
  • Flight School:
  • Instructional Flight:
  • Pilot Certification: Private Pilot
  • IFR Rating: No
  • Pilot Error: Yes
  • Pilot Medical: 3rd Class Medical
  • Pilot Incapacitation: No

Analysis

  • Date: August 29th, 2024
  • Time: 3:40 PM Local Time
  • Day / Night: Day
  • VMC / IMC: VMC
  • Phase Of Flight: Go-Around
  • Total People Onboard: 2
  • PIC Fatality: 1
  • PAX Fatalities: 1
  • Ground Fatalities: 0
  • Total Fatalities: 2
  • NTSB No: WPR24FA288
  • NTSB Travel: Unknown
  • AQP Classification: 16) MESSED UP GO-AROUND, U-FIT

Probable Cause

DTSB: The DTSB determines the Probable Cause of this accident to be Pilot Error, in that the pilot elected to make a downwind landing to a runway known as “one way in, one way out.” and then attempted a low energy go around into rising terrain. A witness, located outside the runway, reported that he initially observed the airplane make a downwind approach to runway 17 at an unusually high altitude. He watched as the airplane landed almost midfield. It appeared to be traveling fast with full flaps and touched down in a flat pitch attitude with almost no flare. The airplane then bounced two times while remaining in the same flat pitch attitude as it traveled down the runway. After the second bounce, with about ¼ of the runway length remaining, the nose aggressively dropped, and the airplane landed hard. It did not appear to slow down, and with the runway end approaching he heard the engine speed increase, and it became apparent the pilot was attempting a takeoff. The airplane then began to climb but with an aggressive nose up attitude such that he could see the full overhead profile of the airplane. The witness said that from his vantage point it appeared that the pilot was trying to avoid terrain at the end of the runway. The airplane then rolled left and descended behind the trees as the roll continued, and a few seconds later a fireball was observed emitting from the trees. The probable Cause of this accident is equally a non stabilized approach in conjunction with a messed up go around.

NTSB: 

Recommendation

DTSB: The DTSB recommends that all pilots of all aircraft are careful to fly all approaches at Vref to Vref plus five, and be prepared to go around very early if the approach becomes un stable in any way. For this particular airport, the decision to go around was reached far too late in the approach and it was not possible for the aircraft to out climb the rising terrain. The DTSB recommends that pilots choosing to fly in to these type back country strips become familiar with procedures, and take flight training from an authorized instructor concerning these procedures and methods.

NTSB:

DISCLAIMER: All data and Probable Cause listings are “Probable” only. They are based on opinion and educated speculation, and are for educational purposes only. They may contain incorrect information and are subject to change as new information becomes available.