Beechcraft 95-B55 | N73WA
October 8th, 2024 | Avalon, California
Accident Location
- City: Avalon
- State: California
- Latitude: 33.402534
- Longitude: -118.43729
- Airport ID: KAVX
Aircraft Info
- N Number: N73WA
- Make: Beechcraft
- Model: 95-B55
- Aircraft Category: Aircraft Multi Engine Land
- Amateur Built: No
Pilot Info
- PIC Name: Safai, Ali
- Gender: Male
- Pilot Age: 73
- Pilot Hours:
- Flight School: Yes
- Instructional Flight: Yes
- Pilot Certification: Airline Transport Pilot
- IFR Rating: Yes
- Pilot Error: Yes
- Pilot Medical: 2nd Class Medical
- Pilot Incapacitation: No
Analysis
- Date: October 8th, 2024
- Time: 8:05 PM Local Time
- Day / Night: Night
- VMC / IMC: VMC
- Phase Of Flight: Initial Climb
- Total People Onboard: 5
- PIC Fatality: 1
- PAX Fatalities: 4
- Ground Fatalities: 0
- Total Fatalities: 5
- NTSB No: WPR25FA007
- NTSB Travel: Unknown
- AQP Classification: 6) MISHANDLED ABN., C-FIT
Probable Cause
DTSB: The DTSB determines the Probable Cause of this accident to be Pilot Error, in that the pilot took off with a known left engine electrical generator inoperative, and a previously known electrical problem that required ground battery charging before flight. The pilot chose runway 22, which is both uphill and less visual reference at night. After takeoff, the pilot likely leaned slightly forward when the landing gear failed to retract, looking for the landing gear switch or an associated landing gear circuit breaker, therefore allowing the control yoke ease slightly forward. The pilot became immediately distracted and pre-occupied with the landing gear abnormal and allowed the plane to both settle and turn right, likely with no landing light on, and no runway lights available for visual reference. The aircraft impacted terrain in a wings level attitude, after a right descending turn. The cause of this accident is the pilots mis-handled electrical abnormal. Contributing to the accident is the pilots lack of due care in operating an aircraft with a known electrical problem, and the very poor ADM exhibited in the decision to make a fully loaded night takeoff, with no runway lights, with questionable electrical system, in an aircraft that relies on DC voltage in order to retract the landing gear.
NTSB: NONE
Recommendation
DTSB: The DTSB recommends all pilots of all aircraft rehearse and become familiar with, and conditioned with the scenario of remaining wings level and setting a climb pitch via reference to the ADI, during periods of reduced visibility, and that pilots become conditioned to fly the airplane first, and deal with any abnormal second via AQP scenario training methods.
NTSB: NONE
DISCLAIMER: All data and Probable Cause listings are “Probable” only. They are based on opinion and educated speculation, and are for educational purposes only. They may contain incorrect information and are subject to change as new information becomes available.